Upon arriving in Cook Islands to compete in the fourth season of Swimmer's Survivor, Frosti was placed on the Aitutaki Tribe, Aitu for short. When Aitu lost the first challenge, he and fellow Aitu tribemate, Zoe, where the main targets, despite Reynold losing the challenge for the tribe. When it was time for tribal council, he was unanimously voted off. Later he recalled his experiance as "BAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAADDDDDD"[]